The operator of Spain’s electricity grid has vehemently denied claims of a chronic instability in the national energy supply, insisting that fluctuations in the system at the time of the deadly Urda rail crash had no bearing on the safety of powering high-speed trains.
Red Eléctrica Española (REE), the state-owned company responsible for managing the country’s electricity transmission, responded to criticisms from engineer José Luis García Guglieri, who had previously argued that electrical instability may have contributed to repeated failures of the LZB safety system on the Madrid-Seville high-speed line. The LZB system, which controls train traffic, experienced 170 malfunctions this year alone, including on the day of the second fatal rail accident in Spain, which killed 69 people.
Guglieri, who designed the LZB module for the Madrid-Seville line, claimed that the grid’s reliance on intermittent renewable sources—particularly solar and wind—had led to a precarious balance, risking blackouts and compromising the reliability of critical infrastructure like rail networks. REE, however, dismissed these assertions outright, stating that the mix of energy sources at 8:30 AM on October 28—the moment of the Urda crash—was no different from previous days and posed no threat to grid stability.
The company emphasized that no disturbances were recorded in its network on that morning, and that the energy profile—marked by a sharp decline in wind and hydroelectric output while solar and gas-fired generation surged—did not compromise supply reliability. Internal data from REE’s own app, redOS, showed a significant drop in wind power (down 16.17%) and hydropower (also down 16.17%), while solar generation increased by 18.72% and gas-fired plants ramped up by 29.21%. Nuclear output remained below its usual peak.
REE confirmed its operational metrics comply with European safety standards and pose no supply risk. Yet, the company acknowledged that on October 6—a day when grid reserves were strained—it had activated the SRAD (Service of Active Demand Response), a mechanism to temporarily reduce industrial consumption. This measure, part of standard preventive protocols, was not framed as a warning sign but as a routine adjustment to maintain grid equilibrium.
While REE insists that the October 28 energy mix was stable, the engineer’s warnings highlight ongoing concerns about the grid’s resilience as Spain accelerates its transition toward renewable energy. The debate raises concerns about reconciling reliability with decarbonization in rail, where disruptions can cause severe consequences.
As of this reporting, REE has not provided further clarification on whether electrical instability could directly trigger LZB system failures, leaving the engineer’s concerns unaddressed by the grid operator.